Macallan Edition No. 5

My first Macallan and was underwhelmed. Lots of bourbon notes in this scotch with some sherry sweetness. Otherwise it felt a bit flat. Luckily I mooched this from a family friend, and didn’t have to buy it to try it. I tried this coming off the heels of Johnnie Walker Green, and while not a fair comparison, I enjoyed JW Green much more than Macallan No. 5 and it only costs $60.

Loved the nose on this one - tons of apple and pear

Nose - The nose appears to be very young with notes of beer malt, hay, oak, soil, honey and vanilla. It has little depth and is rather flat. Palate - Sharp and predominantly sweet, with a slightly salty and spicy taste in the background. Finish - Like licking honey from a leather seat. Sweet and leathery, with notes of earth and nuts in the background. Frankly, I expected more from a Macallan in this price range. I was lucky enough to be able to sample this whisky first, as a bottle can easily cost up to €200 in my area. It is clear that this whisky is aimed more at collectors than whisky connoisseurs. Overall a forgettable experience, which is unfortunate for a brand with this reputation. "Sub-par" : 2.25 stars | Not bad, but many things I’d rather have.

Solid dram of Macallan sherry cask whiskey. Didn't find as interesting and balanced as the No. 6 Edition, hence lower score. Nice nose and medium body. Finish was a bit short as well.

Clean cut classic macallan